If you find value in content like this, sign up for my Talent Edge Weekly newsletter.
As we are in the final month of the year, many organizations are preparing for or conducting performance calibration discussions—critical meetings where managers from across the company collaborate to ensure consistency and objectivity in employee performance evaluations. One aim of these sessions is to promote fairness by addressing discrepancies caused by “tough graders,” who hold employees to exceptionally high standards, and “easy graders,” who provide overly generous evaluations. When done effectively, these discussions result in more accurate performance differentiation. To help managers prepare for these sessions, here’s my infographic featuring 10 example questions. While not exhaustive or tailored to every organization, these questions serve as a starting point and can be adapted to align with an organization’s performance management philosophy and program. Questions range from Goal Achievement: “What were the employee’s most significant accomplishments during the performance period?” to Obstacle Navigation: “What were the most significant obstacles this employee faced in achieving their objectives? How did they overcome them?” By reflecting on questions like these, managers can approach evaluations more thoughtfully, leading to more objective performance differentiation. Employees can also use these questions to reflect on their contributions and performance throughout 2024.
